Bhagavad Gita Bhashya (Sri Madhvacharya) 3.20
Bhagavad Gita Bhashya (Sri Madhvacharya) 3.20 · 3 · Verse 20
Sanskrit Original
।।3.20।।आचारोऽप्यस्तीत्याह कर्मणैवेति। कर्मणा सह कर्म कुर्वन्त एवेत्यर्थः। कर्म कृत्वैव ततो ज्ञानं प्राप्य वा न तु ज्ञानं विना प्रसिद्धं हि तेषां ज्ञानित्वं भारतादिषु। तमेवं विद्वानमृत इह भवति नृ.पू.उ.1।6 इत्यादिश्रुतिभ्यश्च। अत्रापि कर्मणां ज्ञानसाधनत्वोक्तेश्च बुद्धियुक्ता इति। गत्यन्तरं च नान्यः पन्थाः श्वे.उ.3।8 इत्यस्त नास्ति इतरेषां ज्ञानद्वाराऽप्यविरोधः। यत्र च तीर्थाद्येव मुक्तिसाधनमुच्यतेब्रह्मज्ञानेन वा मुक्तिः प्रयागमरणेन वा। अथवा स्नानमात्रेण गोमत्यां कृष्णसन्निधौ इत्यादौ तत्र पापादिमुक्तिः स्तुतिपरता च। तत्रापि हि कुत्रचिद्ब्रह्मज्ञानसाधनत्वमेवोच्यते। अन्यथा मुक्तिं निषिध्यब्रह्मज्ञानं विना मुक्तिर्न कथञ्चिदपीष्यते। प्रयागादेस्तु या मुक्तिर्ज्ञानोपायत्वमेव हि इत्यादौ। न च तीर्थस्तुतिवाक्यानि तत्प्रस्तावेऽप्युक्तं ज्ञाननियमं घ्नन्ति। यथा कञ्चिद्दक्षं भृत्यं प्रत्युक्तानिअयमेव हि राजा किं राज्ञा इत्यादीनि। यथाऽऽह भगवान् यानि तीर्थादिवाक्यानि कर्मादिविषयाणि च। स्तावकान्येव तानि स्युरज्ञानां मोहकानि वा। भवेन्मोक्षस्तु मद्दृष्टेर्नान्यथा तु कथञ्चन इति नारदीये। अतोऽपरोक्षज्ञानादेव मोक्षः। कर्म तु तत्साधनमेव।
He says even conduct is action—meaning: one should perform actions along with actions. By action one may attain knowledge, or not; the knowledges of those celebrated (like Bharata) are well known. Here also the capacity of action to lead to knowledge is affirmed—those with discrimination hold this. There is no other path. Other means do not contradict the doorway of knowledge. Where pilgrimage etc. are declared means to liberation, liberation is by Brahma‑knowledge; the pardon associated with bathing at the pilgrimage is praised. Yet sometimes liberation is declared as attainable by mere bathing (Prayāga, Gomati, proximity to Kṛṣṇa, etc.)—there the removal of sins is praised. Even there, however, only Brahma‑knowledge is truly called the means to liberation; otherwise liberation without knowledge is utterly impossible. From places like Prayāga the liberation is indeed said to be via knowledge. Pilgrimage‑praising statements do not overthrow the rule of knowledge; similar to how a king’s servant is praised, yet the king remains supreme. The Lord’s words about pilgrimages and actions may be by way of praise to attract devotees, or to remove ignorance. Liberation is by direct knowledge; action is its instrument.